Anglin's Pier Isn't Stuck on Permits Anymore. It's Stuck on Math.
On a Tuesday morning in August, you can still get a table at Anglin's Beach Café, order the usual, and watch the tide come in past a chain-link fence that has separated Lauderdale-By-The-Sea from its own fishing pier since a section of it dropped into the ocean during Hurricane Nicole in November 2022. The café never closed. The pier hasn't reopened. For most of the past four years, residents have been told the holdup was paperwork: the Army Corps of Engineers, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Broward County's environmental review. That explanation isn't wrong, but it's no longer the whole story, and the April 2026 town commission meeting made that clear in a way the previous updates hadn't.
The geotechnical work is done. The federal wildlife concerns that stalled the project for years are largely resolved. What's actually holding the pier closed now isn't a stamp somebody hasn't gotten around to issuing. It's a private owner running the numbers on a $20 million rebuild against a bait shop and an admission fee, and a town that has said, plainly, that it has no legal authority to make him move faster.
At the April 14 commission meeting, Development Services Director Jhanelle Campbell updated commissioners on the pier's status, and the phrase that stuck was "full replacement." That's a different project than the repair the town has been tracking since 2019. Pier owner Spiro Marchelos told commissioners the geotechnical borings are complete and the project is now in design and coordination, which sounds like progress and, technically, is. But it also confirmed something residents following the saga had suspected for a while: this isn't a patch job anymore. The pier that reopens, whenever that happens, will be a new structure built from scratch, not the one that's stood at 2 Commercial Boulevard since 1963.
Campbell also reported the running total on code compliance fines: $375,000, accruing at $200 a day since a special magistrate ordered work to resume back in January 2022. For comparison, a 2023 hearing put that total at just over $145,000. The fines have more than doubled in three years, and they show no sign of stopping, because the thing they're meant to pressure into happening still hasn't happened.
The meeting ran nearly an hour, and by most accounts it got heated. Commissioner Richard DeNapoli and Mayor Edmund Malkoon both questioned why the pier was even on the agenda, with Malkoon noting the town doesn't have "skin in the game." That's a notably different tone than the one town officials struck a few years earlier, when then-Mayor Chris Vincent called the pier "an integral part of what Lauderdale-By-The-Sea is" and the town enlisted a sitting congressman to help push federal agencies along.
The legal position hasn't changed. The town has never owned the pier, doesn't run it, and has said repeatedly that its only real lever is the special magistrate process, which fines the owner but can't force construction. What's changed is the willingness to keep saying that out loud in public meetings, which tells you something about how tired everyone involved has gotten after nine years since Hurricane Irma first damaged the structure in 2017.
Marchelos, for his part, didn't sound tired so much as frustrated. He told the commission the whole situation feels like "a waste of my time, my money, my lawyers and everything," and argued that everyone stands to profit from a rebuilt pier except him. That's the part of the meeting worth sitting with, because it's the actual mechanism behind the delay.
A pier's revenue comes from a handful of sources: bait shop rent, admission fees for sightseers and anglers, maybe a small concession. None of that comes close to covering a $20 million construction cost, a figure first reported back in 2023 and still the working estimate for a full rebuild. Marchelos isn't wrong that the math doesn't pencil out from operations alone. Whatever return he sees on this investment will have to come from somewhere other than turnstile revenue, whether that's property value, long-term lease structuring, or simply protecting an asset he already owns outright.
That's a different calculation than "get the permits, hire a contractor, build it." It's the calculation a private owner runs when the project in front of him costs far more than it will ever earn back directly, and it explains a pattern residents have noticed for years: permits get approved, and then months pass anyway. The Army Corps authorization for test borings came through in July 2025. The borings themselves wrapped in January 2026. Each step clears one obstacle without visibly speeding up the next one, because the obstacle that actually sets the pace, the owner's own return on a $20 million outlay, was never a permitting problem in the first place.
None of this has touched the two things that gave the pier its identity independent of the physical structure. Anglin's Beach Café, right at the base of the pier, has stayed open through the entire closure, hurricanes included. It's the one constant in a story that's otherwise been redesigns, storm damage, and unmet deadlines.
The other is offshore. Anglin Reef, named for the pier, runs parallel to the shoreline just past the swim area and remains one of the more reliable second dives for boats coming back from the Fort Lauderdale wreck sites. Divers still find schooling surgeonfish, sea turtles, and the occasional moray on the reef's 10 to 12 foot ledge, regardless of whether the structure onshore has a working deck. The name persists even where the pier itself doesn't.
The town has taken its own precautions in the meantime. Last year, it closed the beach area one block north and one block south of the pier to swimmers and fishermen, a safety measure around a structure that's been fenced off since the building official posted it as unsafe in late 2022.
The town's published timeline, updated as new information comes in, points to bidding on contractors in May 2026 and a two-year construction window starting in July 2026, which would put a reopening somewhere around summer 2028. That's the optimistic version, and it comes with a caveat worth taking seriously: it presumes no named storms hit the site between now and then. Given that the two events most responsible for the pier's current condition were both named storms, that's not a small assumption.
It's also worth remembering how long "two years" has already stretched. A 2019 repair permit came with a completion date of March 2019. That date slipped to March 2020. COVID stopped things entirely. Then Hurricane Nicole made the original repair scope obsolete. Every prior estimate of "two more years" has been wrong in the same direction, and there's no obvious reason the current one breaks that pattern, especially now that the project has shifted from repair to full replacement.
For residents, the practical takeaway isn't cynicism. It's recalibration. The signal to watch isn't the next permit approval, most of the heavy federal and state review is already behind this project. The signal that will actually mean something is a construction contract with Marchelos's name on it, because that's the moment the private math finally resolves in favor of building. Until then, the café stays open, the reef stays named, and the fence stays up.
Lauderdale-By-The-Sea changes in details like this one long before it shows up in any market report, and keeping track of what's actually happening on the ground, not just what's been announced, is part of how Tagliamonte & Associates stays useful to the people who already call this stretch of coast home. If you're weighing what any of this means for your own property here or elsewhere along the corridor, Request a Confidential Home Valuation and we'll talk through it directly.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
A top South Florida producer since 2000 and recognized as in the top ½% of real estate producers nationally, Sandra Tagliamonte and Tagliamonte and Associates take pride in their ability to assist clients in the most effective and successful ways.
